I've been listening to Pet Sounds a lot lately. Maybe it's the dreary weather; whenever I put on some Beach Boys things feel a bit sunnier. But it's a heck of a record (as I'm sure most of you know) - one of those rarified few that's hard to chop down entirely.
It's also fascinating that it's one on a rather short list of pop albums that have supported its own box set. The sprawling The Pet Sounds Sessions, released in 1997, chronicles the process of the album through alternate mixes, outtakes, other session excerpts and - perhaps most notably - the first-time stereo mix of the record. It was and is a fascinating listen.
So much so, in fact, that I've scoured many a discography lately trying to think of some albums that are worthy of such a treatment. There are already several album/box sets out there I can immediately think of. The Stooges had a few album boxes: Rhino Handmade released the massive 1970: The Complete Fun House Sessions box in 1999, and Raw Power was tackled twice (one six-disc set by Easy Action Records in 2005 and the triple-disc box coming from Legacy this April).
Legacy has done a few album boxes based on some of their best-known singer-songwriters. Bruce Springsteen's Born to Run got the deluxe treatment in 2005, adding two DVDs to the mix. A similar approach was taken for Billy Joel's The Stranger in 2008, which added an unreleased live set and a DVD. (Lightning will strike again soon, as Springsteen has discussed plans to do a similar box set for Darkness on the Edge of Town.)
I'm sure there are more. But as with most remastered-music discussions on The Second Disc, I'm interested as much in what can be as I am in what already is. To that end, I offer just a few ideas to the album/box set idea pile. As always, though, I would love to hear your ideas, too. Read on after the jump.
- Michael Jackson, Thriller: yes, it's the best-selling record ever. Yes, it's been reissued twice. No, none of those reissues have gotten anywhere near to definitive status. In addition to the many demos they could include (heck, the many demos they could re-include - why did the 2001 reissue only include 90 seconds of the "Carousel" demo?), there are plenty of alternate takes and mixes in the vault. (Fascinating facts: the original lineup for Thriller lacked many of the classics we know and love today - no "Beat It," no "Billie Jean," etc. What could the other songs possibly have been?!)
- Prince, Dream Factory/Crystal Ball/Sign "O" the Times: when the double-LP Sign "O" the Times came out in 1987 it was hailed as a masterpiece by critics. If only they knew what it took to come out. The album - Prince's first after dissolving The Revolution in 1986 - was rooted in project from two years prior called Dream Factory, a double-album credited to Prince and The Revolution. After Prince sidetracked himself with the Parade album and disbanded his band, he sought to issue an expanded, triple-disc version of Dream Factory, now known as Crystal Ball, but Warner Bros. forced him to cut the set to a double album, which became Sign. Parallel to that, there was the infamous Black Album as well as a planned side project, "Camille," which called for songs sung by Prince and sped up to sound as if a woman had performed them. Were all of this to be released on one box set, you'd have quite a compilation on your hands.
- The Beatles, Get Back/Let It Be: it may not be their absolute best album, but perhaps more than any of The Beatles' albums, this one would be interesting to give a full box treatment. If one could track through all the sessions and mixes that ended up on this record - not to mention the Let It Be film, one of the biggest rockumentaries unavailable on DVD - well, it wouldn't make up for splitting the stereo and mono boxes, but it would be something indeed.
Hank says
The story of Dylan's "Blood On The Tracks" has been told many times--essentially, he re-recorded a bunch of songs on the album after a promo containing the original versions was released. Rumors of Columbia releasing a deluxe version of the album have floated around for years. Will it ever happen?
(Interestingly, the "alternate versions" of these "Blood On The Tracks" cuts included on the 1991 "Bootleg Series Vol. 1-3" boxed set were not the same alternate versions found on this promo, but alternate versions of those alternate versions.)
Shaun says
I was going suggest this, but you beat me to it Hank... I thought we might get a 30th anniversary Deluxe Edition of Blood On the Tracks, then I thought we might get a 35th anniversary, but still nothing.
Will says
U2's Achtung Baby was unofficially accompanied by the 3-CD set out of outtakes and demos and riffs called Salome. This bootleg arose because U2 were trading DATs back and forth with Eno. (There's also a version with a few more discs of drumming, but that would be a bit much.) I'd buy an official release, based on Salome. Or indeed, based on unknown tapes of other material from those exceptionally fruitful sessions.
Sean Anglum says
Well, Mike, if you are familiar with the original UK release of "Let It Be," you know that the book (The Beatles "Get Back") for your box is already in existence. And a marvelous book it is....quite handsome, with many wonderful excerpts of dialogue from the film and a fantastic collection of color photography from the project. A reprint/update of this book (with better binding...those who own one know what I'm talking about) would be a welcome component of the L.I.B. box. But I'm not holding me breath that it will ever materialize (in my lifetime, at least).
Bill Kopp says
Mike, you might know this already...among collectors there is an 83-cd set (that is not a typo) of Get Back/Let it Be material. And it's great. It's called "A/B Road: The Complete Get Back Sessions."
And there's a box's worth of material from the original SMiLE sessions. Anybody who loves Pet Sounds enough to pop for that box needs to seek out the SMiLE sessions as well.
Shaun says
The Deluxe Edition of The Stranger was an odd duck, given that it was supposed to be the 30th anniversary edition but actually missed that anniversary (the original is from 1977).
My biggest objection, however, is that the CD from Carnegie Hall is woefully incomplete. For a few bucks more, I'd have happily ponied up to have the complete show (spread across two CDs). What they released is great, but it's just not good enough knowing that it's an incomplete show.
Actually, given that Billy is Columbia's top-selling aritst ever, I'm surprised there haven't been more Sony Legacy releases of complete concerts on CD or DVD . London 1984 (aired on the BBC but never in the States) would be a great choice. A complete Yankee Stadium show from 1990 would be another.
Shaun says
Come to think of it... There was supposed to be a DVD of Billy's two shows from Shea Stadium in 2008, but that never happened either. What gives?
Shaun says
Let It Be still not on DVD... That's just a travesty. Then again, so is the Yellow Submarine movie having been on available on DVD, and now it's out of print. What happened with that? I'd love to have it.