The set appropriately enough begins with "Solitary Man" and continues for its first two discs in more or less chronological fashion (nothing has been included from Diamond's handful of pre-Bang recordings) with most of his chart singles for Bang, UNI and Columbia Records including "Cherry, Cherry," "Girl, You'll Be a Woman Soon," "Sweet Caroline," "Cracklin' Rosie," "I Am...I Said," "Song Sung Blue," "Play Me," "Be," "Beautiful Noise," and "If You Know What I Mean." Diamond has peppered his tracklist with some lesser-known songs such as "Sunday Sun" (No. 68 Pop, 1968) and "Skybird" (No. 75, 1975) and its B-side, "Lonely Looking Sky."
The third disc has the massive hit "You Don't Bring Me Flowers," although it appears to be in Diamond's original solo version rather than the smash duet with Barbra Streisand, which topped the Hot 100 in 1978. It also has "Forever in Blue Jeans" (which inspired this collection's cover artwork) and highlights from the 1980s up through Diamond's last non-holiday studio album, 2014's Melody Road. (A few albums aren't represented, including Primitive, The Best Years of Our Lives, Lovescape, and his 1990 series of covers albums.) The set comes to a close with the top 10 Pop hit "America," one of three tracks from The Jazz Singer.
New liner notes are promised for this collection, hopefully by the artist; his entertaining recollections for 2011's The Bang Years earned the artist a Grammy Award nomination. The 50th Anniversary Collection arrives just as Diamond is about to launch an extensive tour. It begins on April 7 at the SaveMart Center in Fresno, California and concludes on August 10 with two nights at Los Angeles' Forum. This 3-CD release is due from Capitol Records on March 31 and can be pre-ordered at the links below!
Neil Diamond, 50: The 50th Anniversary Collection (Capitol/UMe, 2017) (Amazon U.S. / Amazon U.K. / Amazon Canada Links TBD)
CD 1
- Solitary Man
- Cherry, Cherry
- I've Got The Feeling (Oh No No)
- You Got To Me
- Girl, You'll Be A Woman Soon
- I'm A Believer
- Thank The Lord For The Night Time
- Red, Red Wine
- Sunday Sun
- Shilo
- Kentucky Woman
- Brooklyn Roads
- Glory Road
- Holly Holy
- And The Grass Won't Pay No Mind
- Sweet Caroline
- Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show
CD 2
- Done Too Soon
- Soolaimon
- Cracklin' Rosie
- Crunchy Granola Suite
- I Am...I Said
- Stones
- Morningside
- Song Sung Blue
- Play Me
- Be - Recapitulation And Farewell To Fletcher
- Skybird
- Lonely Looking Sky
- I've Been This Way Before
- Longfellow Serenade
- Beautiful Noise
- Street Life
- If You Know What I Mean
CD 3
- Desirée - Single Version
- You Don't Bring Me Flowers
- Forever In Blue Jeans
- September Morn
- The Story Of My Life
- Yesterday's Songs
- I Believe In Happy Endings
- Hello Again
- Love On The Rocks
- Heartlight
- Lady-Oh
- Pretty Amazing Grace
- Hell Yeah
- We
- The Art Of Love
- America (From 'The Jazz Singer' Soundtrack)
CD 1, Tracks 1-3 from The Feel of Neil Diamond, Bang BLPS 214, 1966
CD 1, Tracks 4-8 from Just for You, Bang BLPS 217, 1967
CD 1, Tracks 9 & 12 from Velvet Gloves and Spit, UNI 73030, 1968
CD 1, Track 10 likely from Velvet Gloves and Spit (second pressing), UNI 73030-N, 1970 or possibly one of earlier Bang recordings
CD 1, Track 11 from Bang single B-551, 1967
CD 1, Tracks 13, 15 & 17 from Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show, UNI 73047, 1969
CD 1, Track 14 from Touching You, Touching Me, UNI 73071, 1969
CD 1, Track 16 added to Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show, repress of UNI 73047, 1969
CD 2, Tracks 1-3 from Tap Root Manuscript, UNI 73092, 1970
CD 2, Tracks 4-6 from Stones, UNI 93106, 1971
CD 2, Tracks 7-9 from Moods, UNI 93136, 1972
CD 2, Tracks 10-12 from Jonathan Livingston Seagull: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack, Columbia KS 32550, 1973
CD 2, Tracks 13-14 from Serenade, Columbia PC 32919, 1974
CD 2, Tracks 15-17 and CD 3, Track 11 from Beautiful Noise, Columbia PC 33965, 1976
CD 3, Track 1 from Columbia single 3-10657, 1977
CD 3, Tracks 2-3 from You Don't Bring Me Flowers, Columbia FC 35625, 1978
CD 3, Track 4 from September Morn, Columbia FC 36121, 1979
CD 3, Track 5 from Headed for the Future, Columbia CK 40368, 1986
CD 3, Track 6 from On the Way to the Sky, Columbia TC 37628, 1981
CD 3, Track 7 from Three Chord Opera, Columbia CK 85500, 2001
CD 3, Tracks 8-9 & 16 from The Jazz Singer: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack, Capitol SWAV-512120, 1980
CD 3, Track 10 from Heartlight, Columbia TC 38359, 1982
CD 3, Track 12 from Home Before Dark, American/Columbia 88697 28078 2, 2008
CD 3, Tracks 13 & 14 from 12 Songs, American/Columbia 8-2876-77508-2, 2005
CD 3, Track 15 from Melody Road, Capitol B002214902, 2014
Sean Anglum says
An amazing Disc 1 with, at least, one of the strongest 8 song stretches (tracks 1-8) in recorded pop history! Though I lost some interest in his recorded works represented on Discs 2 and 3, his early recordings are stuff legends are (were) made of.
Shaun says
Disc 2 is not quite as strong as disc 1, no, but, a few quibbles aside, still pretty damned good.
Disc 3 is mostly schlock though. They should've stopped with the songs from The Jazz Singer and skipped everything else up until the two Rick Rubin-produced albums: 12 Songs and Home Before Dark). End there. Neil's choosing to not continue with Rubin was a bad choice. In fact, the lack of representation from the Rubin albums hurts the entire collection. Would've been cool to maybe dig up an outtake or two from those sessions?
Really, the whole collection suffers from too many familiar hits, not enough "deep tracks" that Neil might've felt a connection to. THAT might've made this set more interesting.
Not sure why "Lady-O" is so far out of sequence (it's from 1976's Beautful Noise). It should really should be on disc 2.
Anyhow. Given the up and (very) down nature of Neil's career, and since I have a couple of nice collections of his stronger, early songs (The Bang Years, and the old Glory Road collection, not to mention Hot August Night), I don't see the need for this set.
Not to mention, that cover art is REALLY cheesy.
Bill Janowski says
Disc 3 really doesn't look too bad, at least not to me. I do agree about there being way too many repeats from other collections. If I could win this, then maybe - otherwise I'll probably pass.
Shaun says
Well, your mileage may vary on the latter-day Neil. I am not a super-fan, like my wife and her sisters are, but even my wife has little use for 80s and 90s Neil.
The Jazz Singer songs are pretty good (though I could go the rest of my life without hearing "America"), but after that there's not a lot that I care for until those wonderful Rubin-produced albums. Then he took a step backward again after moving on without Rubin (in my opinion, again YMMV).
As Sean Anglum before me commented, it's the early stuff that's really made Neil the legend he is. His Bang-era stuff, up through the Beautiful Noise album is Neil's golden-era for me. That's as strong a run as just about artist could ever hope for (and includes the underrated gem Serenade).
Not to mention I'd put Hot August Night on the list of Best Live Albums Ever, not far behind the likes of Live at Leeds, Europe '72, the Allmans at Fillmore East, etc. Very different from those other albums, but in its own way also one of the greats.
dishy says
is this an improvement over his first comprehensive box from a few years back? Don't think so!
Rob Maurer says
I agree. No reason to dump or replace "In My Lifetime" at all.
Albert says
It's odd that his post 82 pre 2000s albums get overlooked yet again. There were a few songs on the radio from that era that belong on a career spanning collection like this. It's particularly annoying when you consider some of the secondary songs that are included.
Bill says
I agree with the reasoning that I fail to see any reason to buy this cash grab if you already own the previous box set. That earlier box, if you already own it, and the Bang reissue are more than enough.
Stefano says
His back catalogue still hasn't been remastered in full. It's about time for Caputol to start off this job in a prper way. And this anniversary year would be the perfect moment, if you'd ask me.
For example his 1974 album 'Serenade', that one has been mastered for CD once with a lot of ugly drop outs, sometimes one channel drops for many seconds. A total disaster (and I'm not imitating Trump here).
So let's hope for a full catalogue treatment. For now, we enjoy this compilation. Never knew that Desiree had a single version. Is that a remixed version or an edit? Anybody?
Kenny says
There is no real reason for any true Neil Diamond to even consider buying this set. Neil has lots of stuff yet to be released on cd (even "The Bang Years" wasn't as complete as "Double Gold") Maybe a new box set is needed. After all "In My Lifetime" is now 20 years old.
Mark bedard says
I think capitol should go to the vaults, search out the original master recordings ; use the most advanced remastering techniques available, 24 bit 96k or even MQA; and recruit a competent and highly regatded engineer (bill inglot) and the original producers if available and do the job right, neil deserves it!
All his most popular songs, overlooked gems, b sides, outtakes, should be included. Liner notes, commentary, pictures, etc should be included in a nice box set. Nothing cheesey, Start with the Bang years and go through the years in life chapters. The first hot august night should be include in its entirity.
Zubb says
I would have preferred a complete singles (A's and B's) multi CD set.
Reed says
If Neil wants to commemorate his 50 years, then film one of his upcoming concerts and release that as a Blu-ray/CD. He blew it again when he went back to the Greek Theater recently and did not film it AGAIN. Did he not learn how big of a mistake that was from the Hot August Night days? Not buying this set. Have waaaaaayyyy to many Neil hits packages already taking up room on my shelf.
Zubb says
That would not interest me. I would rather see a concert film of his original Hot August Night show at the Greek. Him growling all of his songs live today does not appeal to me.
Patrick says
Worth mentioning this is practically a hybrid or half licensing/ half owned release...the Bang / Columbia stuff owned by Sony while the Uni (MCA) items and the once Capitol-owned Jazz Singer soundtrack both now controlled by Ume or Universal Music Enterprises.
Joe Marchese says
Neil brought his Columbia back catalog with him to Universal in early 2014, so his entire discography is now under one roof (with the seeming exception of the Barbra duet version of "YDBMF"):
https://theseconddisc.com/2014/01/headed-for-the-future-neil-diamonds-back-catalogue-moves-to-capitol-records/