Welcome to another installment of Reissue Theory, where we focus on notable albums and the reissues they could someday see. Now that they're safely ensconced in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, it's time to imagine a deluxe edition of Guns N' Roses' landmark debut album - and we think we made up a pretty good list.
It's safe to say the door has finally, unquestionably closed on the classic Guns N' Roses lineup as of this weekend, when the legendary California hard-rockers were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in their first year of eligibility. Original members Slash, Duff McKagan and Steven Adler, as well as Use Your Illusion-era members Matt Sorum and Gilby Clarke, took to the stage to perform some of their biggest hits for an enthusiastic crowd. (The other two founding members, Izzy Stradlin and W. Axl Rose, did not attend, with vocalist Rose writing a strong but somewhat-measured letter declining his honor.)
Of course, Rose has been shedding original GN'R members since the mid-'90s, and had lost all of them by 1997. And since 1993's covers album The Spaghetti Incident? there's only been one album of Guns material: the long-gestating, semi-passable Chinese Democracy (2008). But no matter your opinion on the mercurial frontman's stance on the Rock Hall induction, it is near impossible to deny that when Guns N' Roses are good - regardless of whatever drama surrounds them - they're damned good.
And, as late '80s rock albums and certainly debut albums go, Appetite for Destruction ranks deservedly high on the list.
From the piercing intro to "Welcome to the Jungle" to the cataclysmic dregs of "Rocket Queen," the dozen tracks on Appetite are caked in grime and danger, arguably one of the realest incarnations of the fear and ruin rock and roll was prophesied to bring to middle America. Even the moments approaching beauty and catharsis - "Paradise City" and chart-topping single "Sweet Child O' Mine" chief among them - are riddled with a nervous edge that threatens to torch everything within a five-mile radius.
Under different circumstances, nobody would have to speculate on a deluxe edition of Appetite for Destruction. If there was any unity between Rose and his former compatriots, this classic album would have been remastered and expanded at least a decade ago. But this is reality, and we have to sort of struggle to imagine what we'd get under the thinnest of conditions.
But it seems possible. Our 25th anniversary edition of Appetite would feature almost no "rare" material, but would get the band's whole output between 1986 and 1989 in print, in one place and in the best sonic quality possible.
A two-disc deluxe set (with the original cover art at right reinstated, naturally) would cover the original 12-track album on one disc. The bonus disc would chiefly feature 1988's GN'R Lies compilation, which combined 1986's Live ?!*@ Like a Suicide with four new tracks, including the excellent "Patience" and the incendiary "One in a Million." (In an ideal world, the Suicide tracks would be stripped of their faux live audience overdubs and presented as raw as they were recorded.)
The bonus disc would close with three live tracks released as various single B-sides (and in one spot on the Japanese Live from the Jungle EP) and one exceptionally rare remix of "Sweet Child O' Mine" commissioned for a promo single by Steve Thompson and Michael Barbiero. (This is different from the standard radio remix of the track, running slightly shorter.)
Guns N' Roses, Appetite for Destruction: 25th Anniversary Deluxe Edition (Geffen/UMe)
Disc 1: Original remastered LP (originally released as Geffen Records LP GHS 24148, 1987)
- Welcome to the Jungle
- It's So Easy
- Out Ta Get Me
- Mr. Brownstone
- Paradise City
- My Michelle
- Think About You
- Sweet Child O' Mine
- You're Crazy
- Anything Goes
- Rocket Queen
Disc 2: Bonus material 1986-1988
- Reckless Life
- Nice Boys
- Move to the City
- Mama Kin
- Used to Love Her
- You're Crazy (Acoustic)
- One in a Million
- Whole Lotta Rosie (Live)
- It's So Easy (Live)
- Knockin' on Heaven's Door (Live)
- Sweet Child O' Mine (The All Dayparts Remix)
Tracks 1-4 released with overdubbed crowd noise as Live ?!*@ Like a Suicide EP (UZI Suicide Records USR-001, 1986)
Tracks 5-8 released on GN'R Lies (Geffen GHS 24198, 1988)
Tracks 9-11 released on Guns N' Roses "Live from the Jungle" EP (Warner-Pioneer P-6270 (JP), 1987) and on "Welcome to the Jungle" U.K. 12" single (Geffen GEF 30T, 1987)
Track 12 released on Geffen promotional CD PRO-CD-3077, 1987
The Japanese EP also featured "Shadow Of Your Love", which also later showed up on the "Live And Let Die" CD single.
That's a fairly succinct compilation. Too bad it will never happen.
Also, I'm a fairly liberal guy, but I don't think the world will ever be ready to have the original cover on the outside of the package.
Jim Regan (@Jbones72) says
you got me excited for a second...would love to see this released though,& purple rain deluxe edition too.
Wow, I never knew about the Sweet Child O' Mine remix. That's wild.
And I gotta agree with wardo on the cover art. Yes, there is a long history of misogynistic artwork in rock n' roll and especially rap, but that rape image is just too much, even if it's cartoon/sci-fi rape.
Good idea, but this is too short for a deluxe edition of such an important album.
Ideally, an expanded edition of Appetite would feature:
Disc 1: Appetite [Original LP]
Disc 2: Lies + bonus tracks ("Sweet Child O’ Mine (The All Dayparts Remix)", "Shadow Of Your Love", etc.)
Disc 3: The Appetite Sessions (tracks recorded in the studio but left off Appetite: "Back Off Bitch", "Don't Cry", etc. + alternate mixes of the tracks on the LP)
Disc 4: Live album CD (for example: 28 June 1987, The Marquee, London)
01 Welcome To The Jungle
02 Out Ta Get Me
03 Rocket Queen
05 My Michelle
06 It's So Easy
07 Mr. Brownstone
08 Don't Cry
09 You're Crazy
10 Paradise City
11 Whole Lotta Rosie
12 Knockin' On Heaven's Door
13 Move To The City
14 Mama Kin
Disc 5: Visual content: uncut Ritz '88 concert + Videos (including censored "It's So Easy")
Disc 6 & 7: Heavyweight vinyl for "Apettite" and "Lies"
Memorabilia: Large poster of the censored cover 🙂
Obviously, none of this will ever happen, at least during their lifetimes (and long live the boys formerly known as GN'R).
While running today, this came to mind, and I started hypothesizing a Use Your Illusion set. Interested to see what you might come up with for that!
Was just thinking about the possibility of remaster / re-release of this album, maybe there will be a 30th anniversary edition? Certainly seems like a possibility now, which would mean a release next year.
DOES ANYONE KNOW IF THERE IS A STUDIO VERSION OF MOVE TO THE CITY?
Jason Meow Meow says
That is the studio version. They added artificial crowd noise like Aerosmith's "Train Kept A Rollin'" There is a bootleg version of the mix without the crowd noise in for all the Pretend Live tracks. You just have to hope you get lucky finding it