Burt Bacharach has been speaking through his music for the past 60+ years, since his very first recorded composition,“Once in a Blue Moon,“ appeared on Nat “King“ Cole’s Penthouse Serenade in 1952. But today, Bacharach is speaking in his own voice with the publication of his first-ever memoir, Anyone Who Had a Heart: My Life and Music. Co-written by Robert Greenfield (Ahmet Ertegun biography The Last Sultan), the book has been described by Kirkus Reviews as “illuminating and gritty“ while Mitchell Cohen in Rock’s Back Pages praised its “tales of multiple takes, artists bravely attempting to navigate those whiplash changes and hat-size tempos.“ (The latter refers to Frank Sinatra’s quip of Bacharach, “He writes in hat sizes – seven and three-fourths!“)
With the book’s release today, it might come as a surprise that no new anthology of Bacharach’s music has been released as a tie-in. Yet. Universal U.K. has planned such a title, but it’s not scheduled to be released until June 10, to coincide with the British publication of the autobiography. Anyone Who Had a Heart: The Best of Burt Bacharach – The Art of the Songwriter is a 6-CD box set (twice the number of discs as Rhino’s definitive The Look of Love – The Burt Bacharach Collection from 1998). The first four CDs trace Bacharach’s career in a roughly chronological fashion, from 1955’s “These Desperate Hours,“ performed by Mel Torme, to 2010’s “Some Lovers,“ sung by Rumer from the 2011 musical of the same name. The fifth CD compiles highlights from Bacharach’s solo recording career (already addressed in full on Hip-o Select’s Something Big box set) and the sixth offers an eclectic array of Bacharach songs as performed mainly by jazz artists.
Here’s where the plot thickens: the set will also be offered as a standard 2-CD edition, but the U.S. and U.K. versions appear to differ significantly, with both 2-CD versions including unique tracks not on the box set (and not on each other). The U.S. release arrives a bit earlier, on May 28.
After the jump: we take a closer look, plus you’ll find track listings for all three versions, plus pre-order links!
The first four discs of the box offer a reasonable survey of Bacharach’s career, getting across its monumental scope. Collectors will likely be happiest with the first disc, which offers a number of songs rarely included in such anthologies. These include one of Bacharach’s very first collaborations with Hal David, Sherry Parsons‘“Peggy’s in the Pantry,“ which still makes the composer bristle today; actor-comedian Jerry Lewis‘“Sad Sack;“ rockabilly star Sonny James‘“Dream Big;“ The Four Aces‘“Paradise Island;“ Everit Herter’s “Boys Are Made for Girls;“ and Dean Barlow’s “Third Window from the Right.“ These songs don’t necessarily foreshadow Bacharach’s future hat-size style, but do offer insight into his development as a songwriter and his ability to tailor material to a wide range of artists in the prevailing musical genres of the day from jazz to rockabilly to pop, country and R&B. Hits on this first disc include Marty Robbins‘“The Story of My Life,“ The Shirelles‘“Baby It’s You,“ Gene Pitney’s “(The Man Who Shot) Liberty Valance,“ and The Drifters‘“Mexican Divorce.“ Listen closely to that last one, and you’ll hear the unmistakable vocals of Dionne Warwick, who would play a major role in the composer’s life beginning with 1962’s “Don’t Make Me Over.“
“Don’t Make Me Over,“ unbelievably, is not on the current track listing to Anyone Who Had a Heart. (An earlier track listing at JPC.de included the song, along with 40 other tracks that have been excised from the most recent line-up.) This collection’s title track, as produced and written by Bacharach and David and sung by Warwick in 1964, is present, along with four other tracks from the "Triangle Marriage" of Warwick, Bacharach and David. The second disc traces Bacharach’s career from Jack Jones‘“Dreamin‘ All the Time“ (1962) all the way to Marianne Faithfull’s rendition of “If I Never Get to Love You“ (a 1963 song introduced by Lou Johnson but recorded by the British singer for her 1965 eponymous studio album). Richard Chamberlain is heard with his original version of “(They Long to Be) Close to You,“ and another highlight is Adam Wade with the all-too-unknown “Rain from the Skies,“ which had the goods to become a pop hit but never did. (The song did, however, become a bit of a reggae standard!)
All of the discs blend original, Bacharach-helmed versions of songs with cover versions from other artists. The third CD is bookended with two covers, Barbra Streisand’s take on “Alfie,“ and Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye’s “The Things I Will Not Miss“ written by Bacharach and David for Hollywood musical Lost Horizon and recorded by the Motown royalty for their Diana and Marvin album (but not released until a CD reissue). These discs take in Bacharach and David’s film work such as What’s New Pussycat, After the Fox and Casino Royale, as well as their Broadway triumph with Promises, Promises. Some of the reinvented tracks heard on the third disc include Elvis Presley’s “Any Day Now“ (his only studio recording of a Bacharach song), Aretha Franklin’s sublimely funky “April Fools,“ and The Stylistics‘ lush “You’ll Never Get to Heaven“ as produced and arranged by Thom Bell. CD 3 ends with songs from Lost Horizon, also marking the end of Bacharach's time as Hal David's partner.
The fourth CD makes a case for what some might call “The Carole Bayer Sager Years,“ though there are also songs written with talents such as Bobby Russell (Tom Jones‘ dramatic “Us“), Paul Anka (Jackie DeShannon’s “I Don’t Need You Anymore“ from the film Together?, Elvis Costello (“Toledo“) and James Ingram and John Bettis (“Sing for the Children,“ arranged in retro Bacharach style not by Burt, but by Thom Bell). This disc also includes Bacharach’s reunion with Hal David on Dionne Warwick’s 1993 “Sunny Weather Lover.“ (Stephanie Mills' 1975 For the First Time, released after Bacharach and David's "breakup," is also represented with one track.) Here’s where there’s a bit of mystery: the earlier track listing showed 28 tracks on this disc, which would be more or less in line with the other discs. The revised list reflects just 19 tracks, meaning that major songs from this period such as Warwick’s chart-topping “That’s What Friends Are For“ and Michael McDonald and Patti LaBelle’s “On My Own“ are both wholly absent from Anyone Who Had a Heart. What the world does need now is a well-curated anthology of this latter period of Bacharach’s career, showcasing the hidden gems alongside the chart hits.
The box set’s fifth and sixth CDs are dedicated to Bacharach’s solo, largely instrumental recordings, and jazz interpretations, respectively. Disc 6 is where you’ll find Sergio Mendes and Brasil ‘66’s “The Look of Love,“ not to mention Ella Fitzgerald’s “Wives and Lovers,“ Wes Montgomery’s “What the World Needs Now is Love,“ and Bill Evans‘ “A House is Not a Home.“ This 17-track disc also had a number of tracks excised from the oriignal track listing such as Dave Koz’s “Don’t Give Up“ and Bill Frisell’s “This House is Empty Now.“
No information is yet available as to the box set’s design, packaging and liner notes content, other than that the cover artwork is based on that from Bacharach’s memoir. Stay tuned, as we’ll report back with that information. In the meantime, those wishing to lock in the current price for the box at Amazon U.K. can order at the link below. (No Amazon U.S. link is available as of this writing.) 2-CD highlights versions will also be available in both the U.S., and U.K., and appear to have very different track listings, with unique songs on both versions not included in the box set. Check them all out below!
Anyone Who Had a Heart: The Best of Burt Bacharach – The Art of the Songwriter will be released in the U.K. in both versions (6-CD and 2-CD) on June 10. The U.S. 2-CD version hits stores first, on May 28.
Various Artists, Anyone Who Had a Heart: The Best of Burt Bacharach – The Art of the Songwriter Box Set (Universal U.K., 2013) (Amazon U.K.)
CD 1
- Mel Torme - The Desperate Hours
- Patti Page – Keep Me in Mind
- Sherry Parsons – Peggy’s in the Pantry
- Alan Dale – I Cry More
- Marty Robbins – The Story of My Life
- Jerry Lewis - Sad Sack
- Gale Storm - Winter Warm
- The Five Blobs - The Blob
- Perry Como - Magic Moments
- Sonny James - Dream Big
- Jane Morgan – With Open Arms
- The Four Aces - Paradise Island
- Gene Vincent - Crazy Times
- Charlie Gracie - I Looked for You
- Everit Herter - Boys Were Made for Girls
- The Shirelles – Baby, It's You
- Frankie Avalon - Gotta Get a Girl
- The Drifters - (Don't Go) Please Stay
- Gloria Lynne - (You Don't Have to Be a) Tower of Strength
- Tommy Sands - Love in a Goldfish Bowl
- Gene Pitney - (The Man Who Shot) Liberty Valance
- Cliff Richard - (It's) Wonderful to Be Young
- Dean Barlow - Third Window from the Right
- Gene Pitney – Only Love Can Break a Heart
- Jane Morgan – Waiting for Charlie to Come Home
- The Drifters – Mexican Divorce
CD 2
- Jack Jones - Dreamin' All the Time
- Babs Tino - Forgive Me (For Giving You Such a Bad Time)
- Marlene Dietrich - Kleine Treue Nachtigall (Kentucky Bluebird/Message to Martha)
- Jack jones - Wives and Lovers
- Jimmy Radcliffe - (There Goes) The Forgotten Man
- Dionne Warwick - Anyone Who Had a Heart
- Dusty Springfield - Wishin' and Hopin'
- Bobby Vinton - Blue on Blue
- Bobby Vee - Be True to Yourself
- Richard Chamberlain - (They Long to Be) Close to You
- Adam Wade - Rain from the Skies
- Dionne Warwick - Walk On By
- Dusty Springfield - I Just Don't Know What to Do with Myself
- Sandie Shaw - (There's) Always Something There to Remind Me
- Dusty Springfield - 24 Hours from Tulsa
- The Merseybeats - It's Love That Really Counts
- Gene Pitney - True Love Never Runs Smooth
- Brook Benton - A House is Not a Home
- Bobby Goldsboro - Me Japanese Boy I Love You
- Doris Day - Send Me No Flowers
- The Searchers – This Empty Place
- Manfred Mann – My Little Red Book
- Tom Jones – What’s New Pussycat
- Jackie DeShannon – What the World Needs Now is Love
- Marianne Faithfull – If I Never Get to Love You
CD 3
- Barbra Streisand - Alfie
- Dionne Warwick - Are You There (With Another Girl)
- The Walker Brothers – Another Tear Falls
- Rick Nelson – They Don’t Give Medals (To Yesterday’s Heroes)
- Peter Sellers and The Hollies - After the Fox
- The Anita Kerr Singers - In Between the Heartaches
- Aretha Franklin – I Say a Little Prayer
- Dusty Springfield - The Look of Love (Casino Royale soundtrack version)
- Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass – Casino Royale
- Roland Shaw and His Orchestra - Let the Love Come Through
- Diana Ross & The Supremes - Let the Music Play
- Dionne Warwick - Do You Know the Way to San Jose
- Jerry Orbach - Promises, Promises
- Petula Clark - This Girl’s in Love with You
- Scott Walker - The Windows of the World
- B.J. Thomas - Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head
- Engelbert Humperdinck - I'm a Better Man (For Having Loved You)
- Johnny Mathis - Odds and Ends (Of a Beautiful Love Affair)
- Elvis Presley – Any Day Now
- Jill O'Hara - Whoever You Are, I Love You
- The 5th Dimension - One Less Bell to Answer
- Aretha Franklin - The April Fools
- Stylistics – You’ll Never Get to Heaven (If You Break My Heart)
- The 5th Dimension – Living Together, Growing Together
- Diana Ross & Marvin Gaye - The Things I Will Not Miss
CD 4
- Julie Rogers – Long After Tonight is All Over
- Tom Jones - Us
- Stephanie Mills - I See You for the First Time
- Jackie DeShannon - I Don't Need You Anymore
- Christopher Cross - Arthur's Theme (Best That You Can Do)
- Carole Bayer Sager feat. Michael Jackson - Just Friends
- Neil Diamond - Heartlight
- Christopher Cross - A Chance for Heaven
- Natalie Cole - In My Reality
- Gladys Knight and the Pips - Overnight Success
- Patti LaBelle – Need a Little Faith
- James Ingram – Sing for the Children
- Dionne Warwick - Sunny Weather Lover
- Elvis Costello & Burt Bacharach - Toledo
- Will Young - What's in Goodbye
- Burt Bacharach with Rufus Wainwright – Go Ask Shakespeare
- Burt Bacharach and Jamie Cullum - Make It Easy on Yourself (Live at the BBC Electric Proms)
- Ronan Keating and Burt Bacharach – I’ll Never Fall in Love Again
- Rumer – Some Lovers
CD 5 – performed by Burt Bacharach
- Bond Street
- Don’t Go Breaking My Heart
- Walk On By
- Alfie
- Something Big
- Saturday Sunshine
- I Say a Little Prayer
- Nikki (Album Version)
- South American Getaway
- The Windows of the World
- Hasbrook Heights
- Reach Out for Me
- The Sundance Kid
- Promises, Promises
- Summer of '77
- And So Goodbye My Love
- I Come to You
- Walk the Way You Talk
- Trains and Boats and Planes
- The Young Grow Younger Every Day
- Another Spring Will Rise
- Don’t Make Me Over
- Futures
- Whoever You Are, I Love You
CD 6
- Sergio Mendes & Brasil '66 – The Look of Love
- Wes Montgomery - What the World Needs Now is Love
- George Benson – Walk On By
- Diane Schuur – Never Take That Chance Again
- Roy Ayers - Raindrops Keep Fallin‘ on My Head
- Ramsey Lewis - Do You Know the Way to San Jose
- Ella Fitzgerald – Wives and Lovers
- Jimmy Smith - This Guy‘s in Love with You
- Lena Horne – Out of My Continental Mind
- Lou Rawls - They Don't Give Medals (To Yesterday's Heroes)
- Charlie Byrd – I’ll Never Fall in Love Again
- Stan Getz – Any Old Time of Day
- Astrud Gilberto – Don’t Go Breaking My Heart
- Nancy Wilson – Alfie
- Laima – Baby It’s You
- The Bill Evans Trio – A House is Not a Home
- The McCoy Tyner Trio – One Less Bell to Answer
NOTE: The above track listing is supplied purely for informational purposes and MAY NOT BE FINAL. It is current per JPC.de. The following songs were ORIGINALLY INCLUDED BUT DO NOT APPEAR TO BE PART OF THE SET as of this writing.
The “Missing“ Tracks:
- Nat King Cole - Once in a Blue Moon (Instrumental)
- Margaret Whiting – Hot Spell
- Jo Stafford - Indoor Sport
- The Hammond Brothers - Thirty Miles of Railroad Tracks
- Jimmy Breedlove - You're Following Me
- Sam Butera and the Witnesses - Love Lessons
- Dionne Warwick - Don't Make Me Over
- Chuck Jackson – Any Day Now (My Wild Beautiful Bird)
- The Exotics – Manpower
- Lou Johnson - Reach Out for Me
- Cher – Alfie (replaced by Barbra Streisand’s recording)
- Shawn Phillips - Lost Horizon
- Michael McDonald - I've Got My Mind Made Up (from Together?)
- Carpenters - Somebody's Been Lyin‘
- Roberta Flack - Making Love
- Quarterflash - Night Shift
- Dionne & Friends - That's What Friends Are For
- Patti Labelle & Michael McDonald - On My Own
- Siedah Garrett - Everchanging Times
- Barbra Streisand - You and Me for Always
- Paul Anka - After All
- Kristen Vigard - God Give Me Strength
- Noel Gallagher - This Guy‘s in Love with You (Live at Royal Festival Hall)
- Burt Bacharach and Elvis Costello – I’ll Never Fall in Love Again (replaced by Ronan Keating’s recording)
- Lyle Lovett – Walking Tall (from Stuart Little)
- Vanessa Williams – Open Your Heart (from Isn’t She Great)
- Burt Bacharach – All Kinds of People
- Burt Bacharach - Monterey Peninsula
- Burt Bacharach – I Took My Strength from You (I Had None)
- Burt Bacharach - Futures
- Burt and the Backbeats - Move It on the Backbeat
- Burt Bacharach – When You Bring Your Sweet Love to Me
- The McCoy Tyner Trio – (They Long to Be) Close to You
- Bill Frisell with Cassandra Wilson – Painted from Memory
- Kevin Eubanks - That's What Friends Are For
- Dave Koz – Don’t Give Up
- Isaac Hayes – Walk on By
- Cleo Laine – Waiting for Johnny to Come Home
- Diana Krall – The Look of Love (Live at the White House)
- Dave Koz – This Guy’s in Love with You
- Bill Frisell – This House is Empty Now
Various Artists, Anyone Who Had a Heart: The Best of Burt Bacharach – The Art of the Songwriter U.K. Highlights Version (Universal U.K., 2013) (Amazon U.K.)
- Aretha Franklin – I Say a Little Prayer
- Dionne Warwick – Walk On By
- I Just Don’t Know What to Do with Myself – Dusty Springfield
- Tom Jones – What’s New Pussycat
- The Shirelles – Baby It’s You
- Burt Bacharach – Trains and Boats and Planes
- Elvis Presley – Any Day Now
- B.J. Thomas – Raindrops Keep Falling on My Head
- Scott Walker – The Windows of the World
- Diana Ross and the Supremes – Let the Music Play
- Richard Chamberlain – (They Long to Be) Close to You
- The Drifters – Mexican Divorce
- Patti LaBelle - Need a Little Faith
- Etta James – Waiting for Charlie to Come Home
- Patti Page – Keep Me in Mind
- Jack Jones – Wives and Lovers
- Dusty Springfield – Wishin’ and Hopin’
- Barbra Streisand – Alfie
- The Stylistics – You’ll Never Get to Heaven
- Gene Pitney – 24 Hours from Tulsa
CD 2
- Dionne Warwick – Do You Know the Way to San Jose
- Cilla Black – Alfie
- Adam Faith – Message to Martha
- Perry Como – Magic Moments
- Sandie Shaw – (There’s) Always Something There to Remind Me
- Jackie DeShannon – What the World Needs Now is Love
- Dusty Springfield – The Look of Love
- Brook Benton – A House is Not a Home
- The Walker Brothers – Another Tear Falls
- Burt Bacharach – Don’t Go Breaking My Heart
- Dionne Warwick – Anyone Who Had a Heart
- Jamie Cullum and Burt Bacharach – Make It Easy on Yourself (Live)
- Marty Robbins – The Story of My Life
- Christopher Cross – Arthur’s Theme (Best That You Can Do)
- Neil Diamond – Heartlight
- Diana Krall – The Look of Love
- Isaac Hayes – I’ll Never Fall in Love Again
- Elvis Costello and Burt Bacharach – God Give Me Strength
- Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye – The Things I Will Not Miss
- Petula Clark - This Girl’s in Love with You
Various Artists, Anyone Who Had a Heart: The Best of Burt Bacharach – The Art of the Songwriter U.S. 2-CD Version (Universal/Hip-o, 2013) (Amazon U.S. / Amazon U.K.)
CD 1
- Aretha Franklin – I Say a Little Prayer
- B.J. Thomas – Raindrops Keep Falling on My Head
- Dusty Springfield - I Just Don’t Know What to Do with Myself
- Etta James – Waiting for Charlie to Come Home
- Marty Robbins – The Story of My Life
- Sergio Mendes and Brasil ’66 – The Look of Love
- Brook Benton – A House is Not a Home
- Christopher Cross – Arthur’s Theme (Best That You Can Do)
- Smith – Baby It’s You
- Gene McDaniels – Tower of Strength
- Perry Como – Magic Moments
- Rick Nelson – Take a Broken Heart
- Brenda Lee – Wishin’ and Hopin’
- Sybil – Don’t Make Me Over
- Elvis Presley – Any Day Now
- Gene Pitney – 24 Hours from Tulsa
- Isaac Hayes – I’ll Never Fall in Love Again
- Ron Isley – Love’s (Still) The Answer
- Dionne Warwick – Anyone Who Had a Heart
- Jackie DeShannon – What the World Needs Now is Love
CD 2
- Tom Jones – What’s New Pussycat
- Barbra Streisand – Alfie
- The Walker Brothers – Make It Easy on Yourself
- Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass – This Guy’s in Love with You
- The Marvelettes – Message to Michael
- The 5th Dimension – One Less Bell to Answer
- Gloria Gaynor – Walk On By
- Astrud Gilberto – Trains and Boats and Planes
- Diana Ross and the Supremes – Let the Music Play
- The Stylistics – You’ll Never Get to Heaven (If You Break My Heart)
- Jack Jones – Wives and Lovers
- Chris DeBurgh – Love is My Decision
- Patti Page – Keep Me in Mind
- Patti LaBelle and Michael McDonald – On My Own
- Burt Bacharach – Nikki
- Manfred Mann – My Little Red Book
- Gladys Knight and the Pips – Overnight Success
- Elvis Costello and Burt Bacharach – Toledo
- Kevin Eubanks – That’s What Friends Are For
Tom says
Hmm, interesting. But the 1998 box set was really fantastic so I'm not sure if I will get this. And I also enjoyed the Burt Bacharach & Friends edition in the Gold series from a few years back because it used a few surprising choices like Sybil's "Don't Make Me Over" (a dance cover) and Luther Vandross' stunning rendition of "A House is Not a Home" (which is nowhere to be found on any of these editions). .
The 2-Cd sets seem to use different versions according to the region. I would prefer for the box set to have all the versions, even if it means repeating songs. For me, that would be "definitive".
Joe Marchese says
Although the unique tracks on the U.S. and U.K. 2-CD versions aren't particularly rare, it's still disappointing that a potential buyer interested in all the music would have to buy three different releases to obtain "everything." One would think a 6-CD box set would cover all of the bases. (Shades of the Steve Winwood box set of a few years back which had unique tracks on the highlights version.)
What's more disappointing, though, are the tracks on the initial listing which didn't make the final cut (presumably due to licensing and/or budgetary issues): Paul Anka's fiendishly-difficult-to-find-on-CD "After All," the rarely-anthologized early material (The Exotics' "Manpower," The Hammond Brothers' "Thirty Miles of Railroad Track," Jimmy Breedlove's "You're Following Me," Jo Stafford's "Indoor Sport"), etc. And regardless of what one thinks of that era of Burt's songwriting, a survey of his career can't be complete without "That's What Friends Are For" and "On My Own" (both No. 1 hits). Even "Everchanging Times" deserves a spot, whether by Siedah or Aretha and Michael.
There are some eccentric track choices, to be sure, but I do hope that this box lives up to the high standard set by the music it contains and by the revealing memoir that "inspired" it.
Magnus Hägermyr says
Thanks for great info! If the "missing" tracks stays missing there will be 41 tracks from the 1998-box "The Look Of Love" absents (10 by Dionne Warwick!) on "Any One Who Had A Heart" even though some of those songs occurs with other artists. And with these two dubbels with different song-index I think the recordcompany is messing with The Great Bacharach Songbook and with his millions of fans. We and he deserves better. But one can hope that since the box is labeled "Deluxe Edition" on Amazon that there will be the same improved remastering as for The Kinks and others.
Anyhow, I'm looking forward to the 14th of June when he's making my hometown Malmö the honor with a consert at our old Grand Theater.
Eric says
Does anyone know why the material from the soundtrack to "The Love Machine" continues to be ignored?
There are two Warwick vocals on it, "Amanda" and "He's Moving On" that are well worth hearing.
Joe Marchese says
Hey Eric, I couldn't agree more - both "Amanda" and "He's Moving On" are incredibly worthy of CD release. But they wouldn't be appropriate for a CD or box of Bacharach songs, as Burt and Hal David produced them but didn't write them. "Amanda" was written by Artie Butler and Mark Lindsay, and "He's Moving On" by Bryan Wells and Ruth Batchelor. These terrific songs are also both testaments to the work of the late Phil Ramone, who engineered them at A&R Studios. Hopefully they'll resurface on a Warwick compilation to come...
Zubb says
Would have been nice to include Merrilee Rush's version of What The World Needs Now from the Bell Records soundtrack to Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice. That track was produced by Quincy Jones. Also missing is Mark Lindsay's recording of Something Big.
Andrea says
let's really hope they don't mess this up, and that they finally come to their senses and restore the "missing" tracks...
Richard says
Thanks, to Joe and others for their Knowledge. Companies should ask fans for input before making these sets. A lot of time and money would be saved. Just once, instead of (some) multiple purchases.
Bill Janowski says
What would I be paid for such input??
Ary Lima says
I’m a Bacharach fan and a Nat “King” Cole collector. So when you wrote that the first BB song to be recorded was “Once in a Blue Moon” from the “Penthouse Serenade” album I was surprised.
In the vinyl edition the composer is Burt Bacharach.
However, on the CD edition (from 1998) the composers were Jerome Kern and A. Caldwell.
Will Friedwald on the liner notes quoted:
“The rarest standard of the bunch is ‘Once in a Blue Moon’ , a Jerome Kern adaption of an Arthur Rubinstein (or so I’m told), first heard in the 1923 show Stepping Stones.”
Curious, isn’t it?
Joe Marchese says
Hi Ary, thanks for writing! While I hold Mr. Friedwald in the highest esteem, I defer here to Burt himself as quoted in Serene Dominic's BURT BACHARACH: SONG BY SONG book (Schirmer, 2003): "That was a song I wrote with my dad when I was in college. And Nat 'King' Cole recorded it. Actually, it's Rubinstein's Melody in F, so it was a real cop or a hats off. Or maybe it was public domain. I can't even say. Jerome Kern also had a song with that title, but you can't copyright titles."
Indeed, Kern and Anne Caldwell wrote a song by that name for the 1923 musical STEPPING STONES, which probably led to the confusion with Capitol reattributing the song to them on the CD of PENTHOUSE SERENADE.
For the record, the original 1952 10-inch pressing of PENTHOUSE credited the track as a Rubinstein adaptation but with Nat himself as arranger. When PENTHOUSE was issued as a 12-inch in 1954, certain pressings credited "Burt F. Bacharach" as arranger and others credited, simply, "The Maestro." Thankfully Burt has been able to confirm that the song is, indeed, his work.
Hope this helps!